Skip to content
Menu
Mesothelioma Lawyer CenterSponsored by Attorney Paul Danziger

Call to learn about getting your best possible financial compensation

800-793-4540
  • Legal Options
    • Pleural Mesothelioma Lawyer
    • Peritoneal Mesothelioma Lawyer
    • Mesothelioma Legal Advice
    • Mesothelioma Law Firms
    • Mesothelioma Claims
    • Mesothelioma Lawsuits
    • Class Action Mesothelioma Lawsuit
    • Mesothelioma Compensation
    • Asbestos Trust Funds
    • Mesothelioma Settlements
    • Mesothelioma Verdicts
    • Asbestos Lawyers
    • Mesothelioma Wrongful Death
    • Mesothelioma Personal Injury
    • Determining Case Value
    • Trust a Mesothelioma Commercial?
    • Mesothelioma Case Rejected?
    • Lawyers by State
    • Mesothelioma Lawyers in Canada
  • Mesothelioma
    • Mesothelioma Treatment Guide
      • Top Mesothelioma Doctors
      • Top Mesothelioma Cancer Centers
      • Surgery
      • Chemotherapy
      • Radiation Therapy
      • Multimodal Therapy
      • Alternative Treatments
      • Mesothelioma Treatment Costs
    • Mesothelioma Symptoms
    • Mesothelioma Diagnosis
      • Mesothelioma Prognosis
      • Mesothelioma Life Expectancy
      • Mesothelioma Remission
      • Mesothelioma Support
    • Mesothelioma Causes
    • Mesothelioma Types
      • Pleural Mesothelioma
      • Peritoneal Mesothelioma
      • Pericardial Mesothelioma
    • Mesothelioma Stages
      • Stage 1
      • Stage 2
      • Stage 3
      • Stage 4
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Mesothelioma Statistics
    • Mesothelioma and Talcum Powder
      • Talcum Powder Lawsuits
    • Mesothelioma and Women
    • Mesothelioma Misconceptions
    • Mental Health
  • Veterans
    • Veteran Claims
    • Navy
      • Ships and Asbestos
      • Shipyards and Asbestos
    • Air Force
    • Army
    • Coast Guard
    • Marines
    • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Asbestos
    • Asbestos Cancer
    • Asbestos Diseases
      • COPD
      • Interstitial Lung Disease
      • Lung Cancer
      • Pleural Effusion
    • Asbestosis
    • Asbestos Exposure
    • Asbestos Manufacturers
    • At Risk Jobs
    • Asbestos Industry Cover-ups
    • Asbestos Laws
  • Settlements We’ve Won
  • Who We Help
  • Reviews of Our Services
  • About Us
Home / Blog / Judge Applies “Thirteenth Juror Doctrine” to Order New Mesothelioma Trial

Judge Applies “Thirteenth Juror Doctrine” to Order New Mesothelioma Trial

Published on January 03, 2022
Paul DanzigerPage Reviewed and Edited by Mesothelioma Attorney Paul Danziger

When Jerry Crawford filed a mesothelioma lawsuit against Covil Corporation, the case seemed like a slam dunk. Not only was there strong evidence in support of his claim of negligence, but Covil’s blatant lies during the trial led the judge to explicitly inform the jury about them. Despite this, the jury found in favor of the asbestos company. In response, Judge Jean H. Toal invoked a little-used legal doctrine known as the “thirteenth juror doctrine” to order a new trial.

Asbestos Exposure from Pipe Insulation Led to Mesothelioma Diagnosis

The evidence and testimony that Mr. Crawford presented to the jury in support of his mesothelioma lawsuit pointed overwhelmingly to Covil’s responsibility. Not only did he talk about the dust raised by cutting the insulation for the steam pipes, but an insulator for the construction company at the site where Crawford work testified that the insulation had been supplied by Covil, and a Covil employee admitted that they’d sold asbestos-containing insulation.

The Covil representative also claimed that all of Covil’s sales information had been destroyed by a fire, but another employee contradicted this and said that the documents had likely been destroyed by another means. This led the judge to admonish the defendant and to order that the jury be told of the lies.

Jury’s Decision in Mesothelioma Case Leads Judge to Action

When the jury decided in favor of Covil Co. in the mesothelioma lawsuit, Mr. Crawford petitioned for a new trial and the judge agreed. Writing that “Under the ‘thirteenth juror doctrine,’ a trial judge may grant a new trial absolute when he finds the evidence does not justify the verdict,” she decided to apply the doctrine.

In her concluding remarks about allowing the mesothelioma victim a new trial, Judge Toal wrote, “Given the overwhelming evidence against Covil on the issues of Mr. Crawford’s exposure to Covil-supplied insulation, Covil’s knowledge of the danger and failure to warn, and Mr. Crawford’s injury and damages, the Court finds that the jury’s verdict for Covil was contrary to the fair preponderance of the evidence.”

She went to write, “The Court exercises its discretion to act as the thirteen juror and, finding that the evidence does not justify the jury’s verdict, the Court is persuaded that Plaintiff is entitled to a new trial.”

Free Financial Compensation Packet

    Financial Compensation Packet
  • Info on law firms that will recover your highest compensation
  • Learn how to get paid in 90 days
  • File for your share of $30 billion in trust funds
Send My Free Packet >

FREE Financial Compensation Packet

  • Info on law firms that will recover your highest compensation
  • Learn how to get paid in 90 days
  • File for your share of $30 billion in trust funds
Send My Free Packet >
Financial Compensation Packet
Calculate Your Case Value >
Paul Danziger

Page Reviewed and Edited by Mesothelioma Attorney Paul Danziger

Paul Danziger grew up in Houston, Texas and earned a law degree from Northwestern University School of Law in Chicago. For over 25 years years he has focused on representing mesothelioma cancer victims and others hurt by asbestos exposure. Paul and his law firm have represented thousands of people diagnosed with mesothelioma, asbestosis, and lung cancer, recovering significant compensation for injured clients. Every client is extremely important to Paul and he will take every call from clients who want to speak with him. Paul and his law firm handle mesothelioma cases throughout the United States.

Full bio and contact info

Navigation
  • Home
  • Legal Options
  • Mesothelioma
  • Veterans
  • Asbestos
  • Settlements We’ve Won
  • Who We Help
  • Reviews of Our Services
  • About Us
  • Blog
Contact Information
Office Address:
1225 North Loop West Houston, Texas 77008

Handling mesothelioma cases nationwide

Call to learn about getting your best possible financial compensation

800-793-4540

Follow Us
MesotheliomaLawyerCenter.Org BBB Business Review
Sponsor: Paul Danziger, Attorney

The information provided by MesotheliomaLawyerCenter.org is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.

  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Editorial Standards
  • Contact Us
©2023 | MesotheliomaLawyerCenter.org